Deadly Colorado Fly Fishing Flies: Top 5 for May

May in Colorado offers a dynamic angling scene as winter’s grip loosens and rivers swell with snowmelt. Navigating the shifting currents and knowing which insects trout target is crucial. We’ll explore key hatches like BWOs, Caddis, Stoneflies, and Midges, and reveal the top 5 essential colorado fly fishing flies to use during runoff. Understanding how the changing game affects fly choice is key. Let’s cast into the details.

May’s Crucial Insect Hatches

Reading the water in May means understanding the menu. The primary aquatic insects active now dictate effective fly selection. Runoff levels and water type—freestone versus tailwater—influence which hatches dominate and how trout behave. Knowing the key players is the first step towards a bent rod.

BWO and Midge Importance

Think of Blue-Winged Olives (BWOs) and Midges as the constant hum beneath the surface noise of May fishing. They are the foundational food source, especially vital on tailwaters or during cooler spells between more dramatic hatches. Their reliable presence means carrying effective imitations is non-negotiable, regardless of what else might be emerging.

Spring BWO hatches (Baetis species) are significant early-season events, often peaking from March into early May. Look for them on overcast afternoons, typically in sizes #16-22. These mayflies are common on tailwaters like the South Platte and Fryingpan, but also show up on freestones. Nymphs and emergers are key subsurface patterns before the duns appear.

Midges (Chironomidae) are the year-round workhorses of the trout diet in Colorado. They hatch constantly, providing a steady food source, particularly on tailwaters where trout often feed selectively on minuscule larva and pupa stages. Their importance, especially in technical fisheries, cannot be overstated.

Tailwaters, with their controlled flows and stable temperatures, are midge factories. This makes patterns like the Zebra Midge indispensable on famous rivers like the South Platte, Fryingpan, Blue, and Taylor. Anglers must be prepared with tiny sizes (#18-26) and precise presentations for these demanding environments. Have you ever been humbled by tailwater trout sipping tiny midges?

Because BWOs often emerge just below the surface, emerger patterns are frequently more effective than dry flies. Flies imitating this vulnerable transition stage can be deadly when fish aren’t clearly taking adults on top. Pay attention to rise forms – subtle sips often indicate fish feeding on emergers in the film.

Caddis Emergence Significance

The Mother’s Day Caddis hatch is a highlight of the May calendar for many Colorado anglers. This often prolific emergence (Brachycentrus occidentalis, #16-18) typically occurs around mid-May, famously on the Arkansas River but also impacting the Eagle and Roaring Fork. It can trigger some truly aggressive feeding behavior from trout.

Beyond this specific event, various other caddis species (Sedges) become active as water temperatures climb. Spotted Sedges (#16-22) and Green Sedges (#12-14) add to the mix. This makes general caddis patterns increasingly important throughout May on both freestones and tailwaters, often with activity picking up in the afternoons.

Before adult caddis flutter on the surface, trout feast on the larva and pupa stages drifting in the current. Fishing subsurface imitations can be highly productive in the days leading up to and during a hatch. This underwater feeding is often less visible but just as significant. Many anglers miss this opportunity by focusing only on the surface.

When caddis are hatching visibly, standard adult imitations are the go-to. Presenting these dry flies with a drag-free drift is usually best. However, don’t be afraid to occasionally skate or twitch the fly; this can imitate the natural movement of egg-laying caddis and provoke a strike when a dead drift fails.

Heavy runoff can sometimes dampen surface caddis activity or reduce visibility. In murky conditions, focusing on subsurface pupa patterns near the banks might be more productive. Emerging insects can still be intercepted by trout even when the water looks like chocolate milk. Adapting to water clarity is a key skill.

Stonefly Nymph Activity

May is prime time for stonefly nymph activity, even before the main hatches ignite later in the month or June. Large nymphs like Salmonflies (Pteronarcys californica) and Golden Stoneflies (Hesperoperla pacifica) become increasingly active and migrate towards the banks to emerge. Fishing hefty nymph imitations is often most productive during this pre-hatch period.

The impressive Salmonfly hatch, featuring insects up to size #4, usually starts mid-to-late May on major freestones like the Colorado and Gunnison. It progresses upstream as water warms. Hitting the peak dry fly fishing can be tricky; nymphing offers more consistent action throughout the cycle. Monitoring local reports is crucial for timing.

Golden Stonefly nymphs (#6-10) are also active and available throughout May, even though their main hatch typically follows the Salmonflies, often starting in June. Patterns imitating these large nymphs remain effective, providing consistent big-meal opportunities for hungry trout. They offer a substantial meal trout rarely refuse.

Stonefly nymphs become particularly important during runoff on freestone rivers. The powerful currents dislodge these large insects, washing them into softer water near the banks where trout lie in wait. One common mistake is fishing too far out in the main current; focus on the edges where fish seek refuge and food gets concentrated.

Don’t forget smaller stonefly species. Early Brown/Black Stones (#14-20) might linger from earlier hatches, and Yellow Sally nymphs (#14-16) become active before their summer emergence. Smaller stonefly nymph patterns can be effective when trout seem uninterested in the giant offerings. Versatility in size pays off.

Top 5 Colorado Flies

Navigating May’s variable conditions requires a versatile fly box. These five patterns cover the essential insect groups—stoneflies, mayflies, caddis, and midges—and prove effective across runoff scenarios and different water types. They form the core of a successful May strategy in Colorado.

Pat’s Rubber Legs Details

This pattern, also known as the Girdle Bug, is a superb imitation of large stonefly nymphs like Salmonflies and Golden Stones. These insects are abundant and active in May before their main hatches. The fly’s simple chenille body and lively rubber legs create an irresistible buggy profile suggesting movement. Black, brown, coffee/black, and tan/brown are standard colors.

Pat’s Rubber Legs truly excels during spring runoff on freestones. Its large size and dark silhouette show up well in murky water, and the kicking legs attract attention. Trout seek substantial meals dislodged by the current, making this a go-to attractor when visibility is low. It represents a significant calorie intake.

Typically fished as the lead fly in a multi-nymph rig, its weight helps it sink quickly through strong currents. Getting deep is often crucial in fast water, reaching fish holding near the bottom. Whether under an indicator or using Euro-nymphing techniques, this fly gets down effectively.

Carry sizes ranging from #4-12. Larger sizes (#4-8) mimic the big stoneflies, while smaller ones (#10-12) can suggest smaller species or act as general attractors. Focus on fishing it in deep runs, seams along banks, and pocket water behind rocks, especially during runoff phases.

Pheasant Tail Nymph Uses

The Pheasant Tail Nymph is a timeless classic, renowned for imitating various mayfly nymphs, especially Baetis (BWOs). These are a key food source in early to mid-May. Its slender, natural profile constructed from pheasant tail fibers is remarkably effective. It’s a staple for very good reasons.

Beyond BWOs, its general buggy shape can suggest other mayflies, small stoneflies, or even caddis pupae. This versatility makes it effective across diverse water types and conditions year-round. Many anglers consider it a confidence pattern that works almost anywhere trout swim.

This nymph is particularly vital on technical tailwaters where BWO hatches are common and trout can be highly selective. Smaller sizes (#18-22) are often needed to match the tiny naturals found there. Fishing these requires fine tippets and careful presentations.

It’s commonly fished as a dropper nymph behind a heavier pattern or under an indicator. It also excels when fished beneath a buoyant dry fly in a dry-dropper setup, allowing you to cover multiple depths simultaneously. This versatility in rigging adds to its appeal. Fish it effectively in riffles, runs, and seams.

Elk Hair Caddis Applications

The Elk Hair Caddis is the quintessential adult caddisfly imitation. It’s indispensable during May’s hatches, particularly the famous Mother’s Day Caddis event. Its buoyant elk or deer hair wing and hackled body perfectly suggest the fluttering natural insect sitting on the water. It’s a must-have dry fly.

This pattern effectively represents various caddis species emerging throughout May as waters warm. Its general profile is easily recognizable to trout looking for adult caddis skittering on the surface. Different body colors (tan, olive, brown) allow for closer imitation.

Thanks to its excellent buoyancy, the Elk Hair Caddis also serves as a superb indicator fly in a dry-dropper rig. It allows you to present a nymph subsurface while offering a surface imitation—a great way to prospect water and cover different feeding zones. This dual approach maximizes opportunities.

A dead-drift presentation is standard during active hatches, often in afternoons and evenings. A common mistake is only dead-drifting it. Try occasionally skating or twitching the fly to mimic the behavior of egg-laying caddis; this can trigger aggressive strikes from otherwise hesitant fish.

Carry patterns in sizes #12-18 to match the prevalent naturals. Observing the size and color of the actual caddisflies on the water is key to selecting the most effective imitation. What size caddis have you seen most often during May?

Zebra Midge Effectiveness

The Zebra Midge is arguably the most crucial pattern for Colorado’s tailwaters. Midges are a primary, year-round food source in these environments. Its simple, sparse design effectively imitates midge larvae and pupae drifting near the riverbed. Success below dams often hinges on this fly.

This minimalist pattern—often just thread, wire ribbing, and a beadhead—mimics the segmented body and trapped gas bubble of emerging midges. The bead helps the tiny fly sink quickly into the feeding zone. Its elegant simplicity is its greatest strength.

Zebra Midges are most effective in tiny sizes, typically #18-24, matching minuscule tailwater midges. Common colors like black/silver, red/copper, and olive/gold allow anglers to imitate various species or adjust to conditions. Having multiple colors and sizes is advisable.

It’s almost always fished subsurface as a dropper nymph, trailing behind a larger fly or suspended under an indicator or dry fly. Delicate presentations with light tippets are usually required, especially when fish are pressured. This demands focus and feel from the angler.

While essential on tailwaters, don’t overlook Zebra Midges on freestones. They can be effective during colder periods, between major hatches, or in slower water where midges gather. Their utility extends beyond dam-controlled rivers, making them a versatile part of any Colorado fly box.

Parachute Adams Versatility

The Parachute Adams is a legendary mayfly dry fly, highly effective for imitating adult Blue-Winged Olives (BWOs) during their May hatches. Its gray dubbed body, mixed hackle, and visible parachute post create a realistic silhouette that sits low in the water film, just like the natural insect.

Beyond specific BWO hatches, the Parachute Adams is exceptionally versatile. Its generic profile can suggest various mayfly species. In a pinch, it might even pass for adult midges or smaller caddis, making it a valuable searching pattern when no specific hatch is obvious.

The parachute-style hackle wrapped around a vertical wing post (usually white) significantly enhances visibility for the angler. This is helpful for tracking the fly’s drift and detecting subtle takes, especially with smaller sizes (#18-24) or in choppy water. You can often see the post even when the body is submerged.

While standard gray works well, specific BWO Parachute versions often use olive dubbing to more closely match Colorado Baetis mayflies. Carrying both gray and olive variations provides options for precise imitation. Sometimes, that slight color difference is all it takes.

Like most dry flies, the Parachute Adams demands a delicate presentation and a perfectly drag-free drift, especially on pressured tailwaters. Target rising fish in slower runs and seams during mayfly hatches. Using the appropriate leader and tippet size is critical for a natural float.

Adapting Your Approach

May fly fishing in Colorado is a game of adjustments. Success hinges on adapting your tactics to the prevailing conditions, whether tackling runoff challenges on freestones or employing finesse on technical tailwaters. Presentation and location are often more critical than the specific fly pattern.

Fishing During Spring Runoff

When freestone rivers surge with high, turbid runoff, trout seek refuge. They move out of the main current into softer water along the edges, behind rocks or logs, and in seams where currents meet. Focus your casts extremely close to the banks and into these slack zones. Avoid wading into these prime holding areas.

Reduced water clarity demands flies that are easily seen. Opt for large, dark stonefly nymphs like Pat’s Rubber Legs, San Juan Worms, flashy attractor nymphs, egg patterns, or streamers in high-contrast colors. These suggest a substantial meal that’s worth the effort for trout to grab in off-color water.

Getting flies down deep is essential in strong runoff currents. Use sufficient weight—either heavy flies or added split shot—to reach the bottom where fish are holding. Employ heavier tippets (3X-4X) to manage larger flies and reduce break-offs in the powerful flow. Dead-drifting nymphs along the bank is the core technique.

Runoff creates hazardous wading conditions. Swift currents and poor visibility demand extreme caution. Minimize wading, always use a wading staff for stability, move slowly, and fish with a partner if possible. Before heading out, it’s essential to check current conditions. You can monitor real-time streamflow data provided by agencies like the Colorado River District.

Periods when flows stabilize or begin to drop after a peak often provide the best fishing opportunities during the runoff cycle. Water clarity might slightly improve, and fish become more accustomed to the conditions. Timing your trips around these stabilizing flows can make a difference.

Effective Tailwater Tactics

Tailwaters in May are primarily about Midges and BWOs. This requires mastering small flies in sizes #18-26. Key patterns include Zebra Midges, Black Beauties, RS2s, Barr Emergers, and tiny Pheasant Tails. Below specific dams like the Fryingpan or Taylor, Mysis Shrimp patterns become critically important.

The clear water and often-pressured trout on tailwaters demand long leaders and fine fluorocarbon tippets (5X, 6X, even 7X). This helps avoid spooking fish and achieves the necessary natural drift. Stealthy approaches, careful wading, and precise casting are paramount for success on these waters.

Achieving a perfect, drag-free drift is the name of the game, whether nymphing or fishing dries. Use small, subtle strike indicators or tight-line nymphing techniques to detect the incredibly light takes common with midge feeders. Any unnatural movement of the fly will likely be ignored.

While midges provide constant action, pay close attention to BWO hatches, especially on overcast afternoons. Be ready to switch between nymph, emerger, and dry fly BWO imitations (#20-24) based on how fish are feeding. Observing rise forms carefully provides crucial clues.

Tailwaters offer consistent fishing and can attract crowds. Consider fishing mid-week, exploring areas further from easy access points, or fishing early/late to find less pressure. Patience and streamside courtesy go a long way in these popular fisheries.

Essential Presentation Techniques

Nymphing is the most consistent producer in May, accounting for the vast majority of a trout’s diet. Whether using indicators, dry-droppers, or Euro-nymphing, getting flies down to the correct depth near the bottom is the most critical factor. Adjust weight and leader length frequently based on water depth and speed.

When fishing dry flies like the Parachute Adams or Elk Hair Caddis, a natural, drag-free drift is essential. Use appropriate leader and tippet lengths, and make necessary line mends to counteract conflicting currents. This presents the fly as a natural insect, not an artificial tied to a line.

Targeting visibly rising fish is often the most effective approach for dry fly fishing. Observe the rise form—is it a splashy take or a subtle sip? This helps determine what stage of insect the fish might be eating (nymph, emerger, or dun) and guides your fly selection and presentation. Cast accurately just upstream of the rise.

Streamer fishing involves casting patterns imitating baitfish or leeches and retrieving them to trigger a predatory response. Effective tactics include casting towards banks, stripping line at varied speeds, or swinging the fly through likely holding water. This method can be particularly productive in lower light or during runoff when visibility is reduced.

Accurately controlling the depth of your nymphs is crucial regardless of the method used. Adjust indicator depth, leader length, or fly weight often. The goal is to ensure your flies drift naturally in the trout’s feeding zone, which is typically very close to the river bottom.

Key Takeaways & Actionable Advice

May fly fishing in Colorado offers incredible opportunities, but requires adapting to dynamic conditions. Success comes from understanding the hatches, choosing the right flies, and mastering presentation. Here are some final thoughts to guide your May adventures:

• Build a Versatile Box: Center your May fly selection around the Top 5 (Pat’s Rubber Legs, Pheasant Tail, Elk Hair Caddis, Zebra Midge, Parachute Adams/BWO) but include key alternates like San Juan Worms, various emergers, attractor nymphs, and a few streamers to cover diverse situations.
• Check Conditions Religiously: Always consult real-time streamflow data and local fly shop reports before heading out. Runoff dramatically impacts freestone rivers. Having a tailwater backup plan is wise if freestones are too high or muddy.
• Match Tactics to Water Type: Use runoff strategies (fishing edges, large/visible flies, ample weight) on high freestones. Employ technical approaches (small flies, fine tippets, perfect drifts) on clear tailwaters, focusing on Midges and BWOs. Knowing where to fish for trout in different conditions is key.
• Presentation is Paramount: How you fish your fly often matters more than the exact pattern. Focus on achieving a natural drift, getting nymphs to the correct depth, and approaching fish stealthily, especially on pressured waters. Sometimes targeting fishing eddies is the secret.
• Prioritize Safety: Be extremely cautious wading during runoff. Use a wading staff, avoid deep or fast water, and fish with a partner. Always know the current Colorado fishing regulations regarding access, seasons, and limits.
• Practice Conservation: Protect Colorado’s precious fisheries. Clean, Drain, and Dry your waders and gear after every outing to prevent the spread of Aquatic Nuisance Species (ANS). Handle fish minimally, wet your hands, and release them quickly.

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. We also participate in other affiliate programs. The information provided on this website is provided for entertainment purposes only. We make no representations or warranties of any kind, expressed or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, adequacy, legality, usefulness, reliability, suitability, or availability of the information, or about anything else. Any reliance you place on the information is therefore strictly at your own risk. Additional terms are found in the terms of service.